Blog

By Mark Olsen, Managing Director at PlanPILOT

What Is Retirement Plan Benchmarking?

Benchmarking is a process where an employer evaluates and measures its plan against others (normally like-kind) to determine strengths and potential shortfalls. Results may indicate where improvements can be made, using defined criteria that may be applied to the comparables in a fair and balanced manner. For retirement plans, these criteria could include plan design and provisions, features and services of the plan provider, investment selection and offerings, and fees and expenses.

Benchmarks are derived from the average of a large sampling of peers. An oft-used term for each criterion is “reasonableness,” or whether the benchmark fits within the range of other comparable plans. For example, “fee reasonableness” is a common watchword among plan sponsors and their advisors to avoid running afoul of ERISA-based sanctions and enforcement from the DOL. Using benchmarks to design and later demonstrate that the plan is adhering to common industry standards is a wise strategy to stay out of trouble and keep your plan functioning properly.

Your Plan May Work, But Is it Really Right for You and Your Employees?

Assuming you’re being a responsible plan sponsor and following the benchmarked criteria, the next question to ask is: Is your plan successful and effective for your employees? As a fiduciary, plan sponsors are required to ensure the plan is working and meets the needs of its participants. Does your plan? It may meet certain benchmarks, but what is the basis for these benchmarks? In other words, the benchmarks may be measurable, but are they meaningful for you and the participants in the plan?

For example, your plan’s “participation rate” (or how many employees participate in the plan) may be 85% against a benchmark of 80%. While your rate exceeds the benchmark, how does it compare with similar organizations in your industry? If others achieve 90% or better, then your plan falls below average and now becomes a shortfall, not a strength. 

Further, is there a reason behind where your standards measure compared to the benchmark?  Are your employees actively seeking self-help financial tools from a provider? Do they have the capacity to participate in the plan, and do they have an active understanding of plan benefits to make sound financial decisions, whether these involve investment selection, deferral rate, or withdrawal requests?

The Benefits of Customization

These questions point to the need for careful plan design and customization. Retirement plan participants often ask their advisors, “How much do I need to save for retirement?” The honest and fiduciary-minded advisor would (or should) state, “It depends.” 

Just as no one car, house, or personal financial plan fits everyone’s needs, a retirement plan should be custom-designed and managed with the individual needs of the plan participants and the plan sponsor company in mind, within the context of the specific industry, the participant demographics, and even the regional aspects of the company and participants. Moreover, knowing the right questions to ask about the benchmark criteria is crucial to maintaining a vibrant and successful retirement plan.

Why a Partner Consultant Could Be Invaluable

Having a team of professionals to assist in the design and management of your plan offers numerous benefits, including the confidence that your plan is functioning smoothly and cost-effectively and meeting the needs of your company and its employees. 

In 2023, just over 100 new ERISA class-action lawsuits were filed. The regulations of ERISA have increased in complexity over the years and the DOL has become more aggressive in their oversight and enforcement. Understanding and managing these complexities takes away valuable time and focus from running your business. This is where a retirement plan advisor can reduce your responsibilities and risk exposure. 

At PlanPILOT, our company is uniquely positioned to help you with these objectives. If you’re ready to upgrade to a new standard for your benefit planning, reach out to us at (312) 973-4913 or send an email to mark.olsen@PlanPILOT.com to learn more about how we can customize our services and your plan to fit your unique needs.

About Mark

Mark Olsen is the managing director at PlanPILOT, an independent retirement plan consulting firm headquartered in Chicago. PlanPILOT delivers comprehensive retirement plan advisory services to 401(k), 403(b), and 457 plan sponsors. His specialties include plan governance, investment searches, investment monitoring, and plan oversight. Mark is recognized as a leader in the industry and speaks at national conferences, including those organized by Pensions & Investments, and CUPA-HR.

By Mark Olsen, Managing Director at PlanPILOT

Managing a retirement plan means the stakes are high for employers tasked with the fiduciary responsibility of overseeing their retirement plans. The complexities of compliance with the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), coupled with the potential for severe financial repercussions due to administrative oversights, and more recently the multitude of mandatory and voluntary provisions under SECURE 2.0, have led many to consider hiring a 3(16) plan administrator. 

This guide is designed to shed light on the crucial aspects of understanding your fiduciary responsibilities, how a 3(16) plan administrator can help you, as well as mitigate risks. While this choice may not be right for every retirement plan, it could be of tremendous value to those wishing to add support to their plans while mitigating risks and seeking to improve the financial well-being of plan participants.  

Understanding Fiduciary Responsibilities

As a fiduciary, the plan sponsor is entrusted with acting in the best interests of the plan participants and their beneficiaries. This encompasses a range of duties, including verifying that plan fees are reasonable, that the plan’s operations adhere strictly to the terms outlined in its documents, that investments are prudently diversified to minimize the risk of large losses, and that all decisions regarding the plan are made with the participants’ best interests in mind. 

The significance of these responsibilities cannot be overstated, as failing to meet them can lead to poor outcomes for participants as well as legal ramifications for those responsible for the plan. Recent surveys, such as one conducted by Alliance Bernstein in 2019, reveal a concerning decline in fiduciary awareness among plan sponsors, with only 44% of respondents believing they are a fiduciary—when in fact all of them are. This trend underscores the critical need for plan sponsors to fully comprehend and embrace their fiduciary duties.

What Is the Role and Value of a 3(16) Fiduciary?

Tasked with the day-to-day operational responsibilities, a 3(16) fiduciary shoulders the complex burden of ensuring compliance with the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), the Internal Revenue Code, and the plan’s own documents. This includes critical tasks such as managing payroll data for accuracy, determining employee eligibility, overseeing plan enrollments and distributions, and ensuring timely and accurate filing of Form 5500. 

By taking on these duties, the 3(16) fiduciary significantly alleviates the administrative load on employers, enabling them to dedicate more time and resources to their core business functions. Beyond mere administrative relief, the value of a 3(16) fiduciary lies in their knowledge, skill, and diligence in navigating the regulatory landscape, which in turn minimizes the risk of costly errors, mistakes, and compliance issues. This protective oversight offers employers comfort, knowing that their plan’s administration adheres to the highest standards of fiduciary responsibility and operational integrity.

Enhancing Plan Efficiency and Participant Satisfaction

By taking over the intricate administrative tasks, a 3(16) administrator works to create a smoother, more streamlined operation—from enrollment to distributions and loans to education. This efficiency not only eases the employer’s burden but also elevates the participant experience, making interactions with their retirement savings more straightforward and less stressful. As participants find the plan more accessible and understandable and gain useful education on topics that many plan sponsors don’t currently offer, their engagement and savings behaviors can improve, which could contribute to their overall financial wellness.

Choosing the Right Services Provider

Choosing the right 3(16) fiduciary services provider is a decision that requires careful consideration, as the provider plays a crucial role in the success and compliance of your retirement plan. When evaluating potential providers, it’s essential to assess their experience, reputation, and the breadth of services they offer. Look for a provider with a proven track record of effectively managing plans similar in size and complexity to your own, and confirm they have robust processes in place for handling the administrative tasks and compliance requirements of retirement plans. 

It’s also important to understand the specific responsibilities the provider will assume and how they will communicate with you about your plan’s status and any issues that arise. Additionally, consider how the provider’s services can integrate with your existing payroll and human resources systems to facilitate a seamless operation. 

Finally, evaluate the cost of their services in relation to the value they provide, keeping in mind that the right 3(16) fiduciary can save your organization significant time and resources, and potentially shield against costly compliance mistakes. Taking the time to select a 3(16) fiduciary services provider that aligns with your company’s needs and values helps maintain the long-term success and health of your retirement plan.

Elevate Your Plan Management: Partner With a 3(16) Fiduciary 

Are you navigating the complexities of managing your retirement plan all alone? If so, it might be worth considering teaming up with a partner to help you elevate your plan and reduce your responsibilities. At PlanPILOT, our company is focused on helping you navigate retirement planning issues so you can potentially achieve better outcomes. 

If you’re ready to consider a 3(16) plan administrator, we’d love to see if we can help. Reach out to us at (312) 973-4913 or send an email to mark.olsen@PlanPILOT.com to learn more about how we can tailor our services to meet your unique needs.

About Mark

Mark Olsen is the managing director at PlanPILOT, an independent retirement plan consulting firm headquartered in Chicago. PlanPILOT delivers comprehensive retirement plan advisory services to 401(k), 403(b), and 457 plan sponsors. His specialties include plan governance, investment searches, investment monitoring, and plan oversight. Mark is recognized as a leader in the industry and speaks at national conferences, including those organized by Pensions & Investments, Stable Value Investment Association, and CUPA-HR.

By Mark Olsen, Managing Director at PlanPILOT

In the multifaceted world of retirement plan management, the role of a consultant is not just to manage investments but also to demystify certain aspects of retirement plans that plan sponsors may or may not think about on their own. Central to this role is the imperative of fee transparency and the efficient management of plan costs. While it may be usual for those of us in the industry to think about these topics, plan sponsors may not consider how fee structures could affect their retirement plans and overall financial outcomes for plan participants. 

This article aims to shed light on the critical aspects of fee transparency so plan sponsors can best help the plan but also relay relevant details to participants. This type of transparency can foster a trust-based relationship between plan sponsors and participants and ultimately benefit both participants and the organization at large. Specifically, we explore actionable strategies for reducing costs, such as embracing technology and automation, effectively managing small account balances, and leveraging recordkeeper technology to enhance participant engagement.

Fee Transparency & Assessing Plan Fees

Understanding and disclosing the fees associated with retirement plans is not just a best practice; it’s a crucial element of fiduciary oversight. This section delves into the importance of accurately assessing and transparently communicating plan fees, laying the groundwork for trust and efficiency in retirement plan administration.

Overview of Relevant Regulations

Regulatory frameworks like the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) play a pivotal role in governing retirement plan fee disclosures. ERISA mandates that plan sponsors must act in the best interest of participants and beneficiaries, which includes keeping fees reasonable and transparent. This regulation requires detailed disclosures about the fees and expenses associated with plan investments and administration. These disclosures allow participants to make informed decisions regarding the plan selections and investments.

To confirm your fees are reasonable and transparent, regularly review your plan fees, including the investment management fees and administrative fees. While others might suggest reviewing plan fees less frequently, I believe this should at least be an annual review.

Benefits of Compliance

Adhering to these regulatory requirements offers numerous benefits. For plan sponsors, compliance with fee transparency regulations reinforces their fiduciary duty, safeguarding them from potential legal liabilities. For participants, clear and up-front information about fees empowers them to make more informed investment choices. Additionally, this transparency fosters a trusting relationship between sponsors and participants, enhancing overall satisfaction with the retirement plan. Furthermore, it encourages competitive pricing and efficiency among service providers, ultimately benefiting the plan’s performance and the participants’ retirement savings.

If you aren’t sure you want to conduct these annual reviews (as well as the compliance requirements that come with it), you can also consider hiring an investment manager for the plan, who could then take that responsibility off your shoulders.

Managing and Reducing Costs When Possible

Efficiently managing and reducing costs is vital for both sustaining the plan and optimizing participant benefits. This doesn’t mean plan sponsors should work harder or longer hours for less money. Instead, the point is to streamline plan operations so you can minimize expenses. By focusing on innovative solutions such as technology integration, effective management of account balances, and leveraging recordkeeper platforms, advisors can significantly enhance the cost-effectiveness of retirement plans.

Embracing Technology and Automation

As innovations continue to advance, embracing technology and automation stands out as a way to change how you conduct your operations. By integrating advanced tech solutions, plan sponsors can streamline administrative processes, reducing the need for labor-intensive, manual tasks. This shift not only increases efficiency but also significantly lowers operational costs. Automation in processes like enrollment, contribution management, and reporting enhances accuracy and speed, further reducing the likelihood of costly errors. For advisors, this means being able to offer more competitive fees, while for plan participants, it translates into a more efficient, cost-effective retirement plan experience.

Managing Small Balances

Another effective strategy for cost reduction is the management of small balances in retirement plans, specifically those belonging to former employees. By rolling over or distributing accounts with balances under $7,000, this will increase the average account balance within the plan. This is a critical metric for recordkeepers when establishing fees. Higher average account balances often lead to lower per-participant fees due to economies of scale. Consequently, this strategy not only streamlines the plan but also has the potential to lower the overall fee structure, benefiting both current participants and the plan sponsor.

Leveraging Recordkeeper and Educational Technology

Utilizing the technology offered by recordkeepers can be a strategic move for plan sponsors. These platforms often provide tools and resources aimed at educating and advising plan participants. By using these technologies, plan sponsors can offer enhanced guidance and support without incurring additional costs. This approach empowers participants with knowledge and confidence in managing their retirement funds. Furthermore, educated participants tend to make more informed decisions, leading to potentially better plan performance, reduced costs, lower administrative demands, and less compliance risk.

Optimize Your Retirement Plan: Focus on Cost Efficiency and Transparency Now

Looking for specialized insights to optimize your retirement plan offerings? PlanPILOT can help. Our dedicated team brings a wealth of experience in retirement plan consulting, keeping your company ahead with the latest industry trends and strategies. With PlanPILOT as your partner, you can confidently offer retirement benefits that meet your participants’ needs while safeguarding a plan sponsor’s interests. 

To explore how we can support your retirement plan goals, contact us at (312) 973-4913 or drop an email to mark.olsen@PlanPILOT.com.

About Mark

Mark Olsen is the managing director at PlanPILOT, an independent retirement plan consulting firm headquartered in Chicago. PlanPILOT delivers comprehensive retirement plan advisory services to 401(k), 403(b), and 457 plan sponsors. His specialties include plan governance, investment searches, investment monitoring, and plan oversight. Mark is recognized as a leader in the industry and speaks at national conferences, including those organized by Pensions & Investments, Stable Value Investment Association, and CUPA-HR.

By Mark Olsen, Managing Director at PlanPILOT

To function as a successful plan sponsor, you need a retirement plan committee that helps your company organize and administer employee plans, such as the 401(k) or 403(b). While ERISA does not require the committee itself, committee members can keep your organization in compliance with all established regulations. To help you get the most out of your retirement plan committee, we’ve compiled several strategies for your consideration. Could implementing any or all of the following enhance your retirement plan committee’s performance?

Commit to Education

One of the challenges of maintaining a successful retirement plan committee is that there are no formal job titles or descriptions. And yet it is vital that committee members have the qualifications necessary to administer and manage employee retirement plans.

For example, committee members should be properly trained to understand their role as fiduciaries. This means acting in the best interests of retirement plan participants and their beneficiaries—and not the plan sponsor. Offering both preliminary and ongoing training can reinforce this distinction in the minds of committee members for a more effective team.

Similarly, it’s important for committee members to stay informed about evolving regulatory issues, such as changes to ERISA, DOL, or IRS requirements. Quarterly training sessions can keep your team apprised of any changes and can also create a layer of accountability to maintain fiduciary responsibility. With the passage of SECURE 2.0, there are a number of important items to discuss for potential plan adoption.

Delegate Tasks Appropriately

One of the most important benefits of a retirement plan committee is the ability to delegate tasks to committee members. For instance, you could divide your committee into segments, each one handling such roles as fiduciary oversight, administrative processes, employee communications, and settlor functions.

Delegating these tasks can also help fine-tune your education and training initiatives. Some committee members will benefit from specialized legal and regulatory training, while others may be better served by learning more about plan options.

Dividing your committee’s responsibilities may also assist in bringing on new committee members. Those with more experience in their committee assignment can serve as valuable mentors for new members and can demonstrate the best practices of retirement plan management. Providing some historical context for prior plan decisions is an invaluable benefit to new committee members.

Reflect Your Company’s Diverse Demographics

Sixty percent of American organizations have some type of diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) program in place. But does your retirement plan committee reflect this commitment to diversity and inclusion?

Historically, access to retirement plans for people of color has lagged behind that of their white peers. Your committee can be a part of your pursuit of inclusion and an accurate reflection of the makeup of your workplace. That starts by populating your committee with representatives from every age group, ethnicity, gender, and socioeconomic background. These representatives can provide guidance on how best to serve the needs and concerns of all groups under your employ—and the benefit is that this guidance comes from your committee’s own lived experience.

Documentation and Transparency

Given your committee’s fiduciary responsibilities, it’s important to document your decisions and activities. Consider appointing a secretary to record agenda items for each meeting, then record the minutes of each meeting and any action items that rose to the surface.

This is especially true when your committee implements changes to your company’s retirement plan. These changes, as well as any salient discussion points that led to those proposed changes, should be carefully and clearly documented. 

Does your retirement plan committee operate under a committee charter? While it’s not legally required, a written charter can help you stay organized and delegate who has fiduciary responsibility. A charter can also contribute to your legal defense in the event of a lawsuit.

Comprehensive Retirement Plan Consulting 

Need a little more guidance? PlanPILOT is here to help! We offer a comprehensive approach to retirement plan consulting, and our consulting services can also keep your company up to date on the latest trends. The right advisors in your corner can help your organization deliver retirement benefits that serve the needs of participants while mitigating risk to your company. It’s a win-win! 

To get in touch, call us at (312) 973-4913 or email mark.olsen@PlanPILOT.com. We look forward to hearing from you!

About Mark

Mark Olsen is the managing director at PlanPILOT, an independent retirement plan consulting firm headquartered in Chicago. PlanPILOT delivers comprehensive retirement plan advisory services to 401(k), 403(b), and 457 plan sponsors. His specialties include plan governance, investment searches, investment monitoring, and plan oversight. Mark is recognized as a leader in the industry and speaks at national conferences, including those organized by Pensions & Investments, Stable Value Investment Association, and CUPA-HR.